ChristiaNet MallWorld's Largest Christian MallChristian BlogsFree Bible QuizzesFree Ecards and Free Greeting CardsLoans, Debt, Business and Insurance Articles

Woman Through Medical Procedure

If a man becomes a woman through medical transition, would marrying this "woman" be considered sinful? They are women by Law.

Moderator - Of course.

Join Our Christian Penpals and Take The Sin & Repentance Quiz
 ---william on 12/1/06
     Helpful Blog Vote (14)

Reply to this BlogPost a New Blog

I agree with most here who have expressed their views. There is no medical procedure that can turn a man into a woman. With surgical reconstuction and hormone treatment, a man might convince himself or others that he is a woman, but his genetics do not change. And I'll bet anyone who is genetically a woman would, in a rather short time, be able to detect the difference on the basis of conversation alone.
---Donna66 on 1/20/09

I do not think its wrong however, I believe that even though by law their legal, biblically he will always be a man because he will never be able to get pregnant and have a child. that is what separates men and women is the womb. I am a Gay man I do not think its wrong for anyone to marry the one they love.
---Troy on 1/18/09

The two will never become the other.
CHOICE makes us different.The power of thought,of change,of control,of fantasy,
of visions can bring things to life.
So,we are what we choose to be.Not what
we have to be.Only one can or is created
to have babies.It don't matter about the change.A woman is a woman.
---Jack_8773 on 1/6/08

It doesn't matter how much cosmetic,and thats all it is,work they have done to make them look like a woman in every way,their chromosomes still are " XY " which is a man,and they can never change that. By God's creation and His Law, "she?" is a man. Yes it is a sin for a man to marry a man and thats what you would be doing. Pray for strength to walk away and find a real woman.
---Darlene_1 on 1/4/08

They might be women by man's law but they certainly are not by God's law. A D.N.A. test done on any of them would, I am sure, show them to be male.
---m.p.a. on 5/19/07

I think the only way it should be acceptable is in the rare case of intersexuals. Otherwise the people are discieving and living a lie, so they are already living in sin, and in that case they are leading those they are in relation with into sin. I'm not trying to be judgemental but if you are desciving you aren't in a truly loving relationship.
---Jared on 12/6/06

The word "hermaphrodite" (erroneously pronounced "morphodite) combines "Hermes" and "Aphrodite".

In other words-- ambiguous gender, sometimes possessing, or seeming to possess, genitals and reproductive organs of both sexes.

The preferred term now is "intersexed".

I saw some tv shows about different kinds of intersexuality, and asked my doctor about it, who replied, "In human sexuality things are seldom what they seem."
---Jack on 12/6/06

As was was born man but did not act as man inside thus was woman inside. Surgery corrects. Lived this life'. tend to believe this was not sin on there behalf. Right or life?
---will on 12/2/06

Noticed how you answer the question with your wording of the question. The question begins with the words "If a man"; and we know a man should not marry a man!
---mima on 12/2/06

Shana - Forgive my ignorance, but what is a hemaphrodite?
---Helen_5378 on 12/2/06

2. In the past some hermaphrodites would have married 'the wrong sex' because of mistakes made both on their birth certificate and by surgeons. This is less likely to happen now because screening, scans etc. are so much better. I have a friend with a cousin who was born 'male' but is now married to a man and has 2 children conceived naturally. Obviously her surgeon made the right decision but it wasn't always the case sadly.
---m.p.a. on 12/2/06

By who's law are they women and who's law did they break to not be men, and further who's law will count more when you die?

I'd re-think this one if I were you.
---Pharisee on 12/1/06

As far as I know the person is a woman and i can not say different and I can not see wher the lead in as to this.--Curious question. No bibical reference......the person acts as woman and carries themself as one.....Thus must be woman!
---will on 12/1/06

If they stop the hormones the body goes back to being what they were born if male the voice deepens,body hair unless lasered off etc., DNA/blood work does not lie it is fact and science- no matter how they have transformed themselves thru surgery.
---Jeanne on 12/1/06

I'm not being silly, but what about hemaphrodites?
---Shana on 12/1/06

Copyright© 2017 ChristiaNet®. All Rights Reserved.